Contestant #1- Sense and Sensibility
(Movie #18) Suggested by Sweeneyville reader Kaylee Adair
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7965e/7965e1e9a71d77ca5bd902e2b3d77167aceaf612" alt=""
Contestant #2- Persuasion
(Movie #19) Suggested by Sweeneyville reader Amy Schmutz
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/67949/67949aa9c991a7f1301cce04fe153c62fd903387" alt=""
Contestant #3- Pride and Prejudice
(Movie #20) Suggested by Sweeneyville reader David Bingham
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1654b/1654b32a680b750f7a413be262afe13bf0895b73" alt=""
Sense and Sensibility
Overall: 9.1/10
Deductions: Delores Umbridge!
Bonus Points: Snape! Rose! House!
I really enjoyed this movie because of the amazing cast of characters and possibilities of how it could turn out. I had absolutely no idea what was going to happen and the last thirty minutes were kind of torture for me. And I actually teared up a little at the end for Ms. Dashwood, well, actually both of them. Loved that the steady, noble, nice guy wins in the end. Plus, I am a total sucker for anything Hugh Grant.
Persuasion
Overall: 9.2/10
Deductions: Two people taking bad falls in one movie
Bonus Points: Her entire horrible family was brilliantly acted, Aunt Petunia!
This movie plot was more of a "will they or won't they" kind of movie. You will like this movie because of three things: The main character, Anne, is the perfect underdog to root for, her sister the hypochondriac and her high-and-mighty father say some of the funniest things, and the dialogue is very witty and quick throughout. Thoroughly enjoyed this movie! And I dare say that you will too.
Pride and Prejudice (Kiera Knightly version)
Overall: 9.4/10
Deductions: Mr. Darcy's giant sideburns and mini mullet were killing me
Bonus Points: Mr. Collins, The MUSIC
I just have to say that I really, really wanted to come away from this movie not liking it so much. Everyone I know loves it and it is by far the most popular Jane Austen story that gets redone and redone and redone. But darnit, I really, really loved it! This is a movie that I have been thinking about since I saw it. I even dreamed about it all last night. At first I was not impressed with Mr. Darcy's looks at all. But he totally grows on you! His hair definitely looked best in the rain. I admit, there are still a lot of unanswered questions for me about it, which maybe is why I kinda have to declare it the winner. But if all these movies were comparable for the most part in how good they were, then I guess the one thing that would push me over the edge for this movie was the music. I am a total move music person and the score to this movie was INCREDIBLE. I even bought a few of the songs off the soundtrack on Amazon this morning. Best movie music score I have heard since New Moon.
So as you can see, they were darn close to each other. It was actually terribly painful trying to pick a winner because they were all different, but all very good in their own way.
And watching all these movies was not completely frivolous, for here are three things I learned from watching Jane Austen movies:
1. Never, ever, EVER get caught in the rain. You will die.
2. Apparently it's quite acceptable and not uber-creepy to marry your cousin.
3. If you don't play the pianoforte, like to take long walks or enjoy gossipping, don't bother getting out of bed :)
1 comment:
I had a tear in my eye as I held back laughter at the thought of our times during the winter olympics. ;) Good, good times. Love you.
Post a Comment